American Idol

American Idol (2002 – 2016)

2002 • 15 seasons • Reality • TV-PG

On August 9, 2026

#2608 ▲ 410

2608th by attention TV show online

28.2 Attention Score

Streaming on See all

Overview Watch Cast Seasons (15) Similar Images

photo from the episode

Episode 12 — The Final Decision...But The Right One?

Season 3 • American Idol

Released: 2004-02-18 • Reality

0%

User score

The second two people to move on to the final group of 12 are...

Camile Velasco

&

Matthew Rogers

Where to Stream Episode 12

Season 3 · Episode 12 · Streaming in USA

JustWatch

Spectrum On Demand

Episodes

Episode 1
First Show, First Recap
2004-01-19

Episode 2
The Journey Continues!
2004-01-20

Episode 3
Night Three!
2004-01-21

Episode 4
Finally! A Show About California!
2004-01-27

Episode 5
Mokolokilikilanilaki! It's Hawai'i!
2004-01-28

Episode 6
The Road is to Hollywood! (Is Paved with Broken Dreams. And Asphalt.)
2004-02-02

Episode 7
You're Going to Hollywood! (For a Little Bit, At Least.)
2004-02-03

Episode 8
87 - People Not Good Enough = 32 Finalists!
2004-02-04

Episode 9
Sing!
2004-02-10

Episode 10
Two Will Be Happy. Six Will Be Sad. Lots Will Be Watching.
2004-02-11

Episode 11
Sing Again!
2004-02-17

Episode 12
The Final Decision...But The Right One?
2004-02-18

Episode 13
I'm Back, Baby!
2004-02-24

Episode 14
You! Over here! With the rest of the finalists!
2004-02-25

Episode 15
Uncut, Uncensored and Untalented
2004-03-01

Episode 16
Group Four! Then the Wild Card!
2004-03-02

Episode 17
Finally! Finalists!
2004-03-03

Episode 18
Wild Card Round (1)
2004-03-09

Episode 19
Wild Card Round (2)
2004-03-10

Episode 20
12 Finalists Have Been Chosen
2004-03-16

Episode 21
Clay Aiken Returns
2004-03-17

Episode 22
1 Down 11 To Go
2004-03-23

Episode 23
Soon There Will Be 10
2004-03-24

Episode 24
10 Contestants sing
2004-03-30

Episode 25
10 - 1 = 9
2004-03-31

Episode 26
Elton John theme
2004-04-06

Episode 27
Tamyra Gray returns
2004-04-07

Episode 28
8 left to compete
2004-04-14

Episode 29
Down to 7 (Battle of the Jo(h)n's)
2004-04-15

Episode 30
7 sing!!
2004-04-20

Episode 31
6 remain - Barry Manilow visits
2004-04-21

Episode 32
6 perform
2004-04-27

Episode 33
6-1=5 is the result
2004-04-28

Episode 34
American Idol: The Final Five 2004
2004-05-03

Episode 35
5 Idols sing
2004-05-04

Episode 36
Only 4 remain
2004-05-05

Episode 37
4 Idols perform
2004-05-11

Episode 38
Only 3 Idols remain
2004-05-12

Episode 39
The Final 3 2004
2004-05-17

Episode 40
3 sing
2004-05-18

Episode 41
Now Down To 2
2004-05-19

Episode 42
American Idol: The Phenomenon
2004-05-23

Episode 43
Fantasia Barrino vs. Diana DeGarmo
2004-05-25

Episode 44
And The Winner Is.....
2004-05-26

Episode 45
Kelly, Ruben & Fantasia: Home for Christmas
2004-11-24

Information

Episode air date	18.02.2004
Episode runtime	85 min
Episode rating	0.00
Genres	Reality
TMDB series rating	5.1
IMDb series rating	4.3
Series status	Ended
Age rating	6+
Country	US

Cast

Jennifer Lopez
Self - Judge

Ryan Seacrest
Self - Host

Keith Urban
Self - Judge

Harry Connick Jr.

Harry Connick Jr.
Self - Judge

Similar shows

The Tonight Show

The Queen of Flow

Friday Night Lights

Beavis and Butt-Head

From the Earth to the Moon

The Twilight Zone

America's Got Talent

Recommended shows

Celebrity Wheel of Fortune

← Previous episode Next episode →