Josie Jennings, a renowned 35-year-old chef known for her romantic spirit, returns to her hometown for the holidays. Her mother, Shannon, has recently opened a restaurant at the charming bed and breakfast where Josie grew up. Food critic Tanner Rhodes, who has previously been critical of Josie's work, arrives to review the new restaurant and Josie’s Christmas menu. As the holidays progress, Josie and Tanner reconnect, and a romance sparks. Can Tanner redeem himself with a glowing review and win Josie's heart before Christmas Eve?